Let us create a 3D eBook for you!
Let us create a 3d Digital eBook for you! DigyCat.com

Aphasia: The Cruelest Language Barrier


Imagine the following scenario: You wake up one morning and instead of speaking English, everyone around you--including your family and friends--is speaking Hungarian. This is a problem because you don't speak Hungarian and you don't have a clue what they're saying. You become frustrated. The people around you become frustrated, too, but instead of switching back to English, they speak Hungarian more loudly.

Somebody gets the bright idea of writing you a note. You take the note in your hands and study it. Unfortunately, it's in Hungarian, too, and you can't read it. So they write you another note, still in Hungarian, but this time with large, block letters. You can't read the second note, either.

This strange scenario is almost exactly what happens to people who have a stroke (circulation impairment) to the left side of the brain, except that the family and friends aren't really communicating in Hungarian. They're speaking and writing English--same as ever--but to the stroke victim their words are suddenly incomprehensible. This sudden disruption in language-processing is called aphasia.

Different patterns of aphasia occur with damage to different parts of the left side of the brain. The preceding scenario, in which comprehension of language is impaired, is called a receptive aphasia and is associated with injury to the upper portion of the brain's left temporal lobe, roughly adjacent to the temple and top of the ear. In receptive aphasia the affected individuals can still produce sentences, but, in an odd twist of fate, they can't make sense of or properly monitor their own words, so their output is riddled with errors.

A pattern of language impairment opposite of receptive aphasia is called expressive aphasia, in which individuals can understand what others say or write, but cannot produce much, if any, speech or writing of their own. In 1861 Pierre Paul Broca, a French surgeon, recognized a case of expressive aphasia and followed through with an autopsy of the patient's brain.

For much of the nineteenth century most scientists and physicians believed that the brain was homogenous, and that its different actions were spread diffusely throughout the entire brain. They did not believe that functions were localized to specific regions of the brain. (The phrenologists believed otherwise, but that is a story of its own.)

However, when Broca treated a patient who lost his power of speech (the only word he could still say was "tan") he was able to correlate this language impairment with damage to the left side of the man's brain. Instead of being in the temporal lobe, the destroyed brain-tissue was in the frontal lobe in an area now referred to as Broca's area. In fact, expressive aphasia is also known as Broca's aphasia. Dr. Broca's case was the principal salvo in a reversal of understanding about how the cerebral cortex (the brain's wrinkled gray surface) operates. Now we realize that many functions--not just language--are localized to specific regions of the cortex.

Receptive and expressive aphasias are not the only patterns of language impairment, but nicely convey the basic idea of a sudden disconnect in language processing. What becomes of these cases? As is seen with strokes affecting other parts of the brain--for example, those causing weakness or paralysis of muscles on the opposite side of the body--recovery varies widely among patients. Some patients become normal again and others don't improve at all, but the usual outcome is somewhere in between.

Improvement in language function that occurs within the first week or two following a stroke is due to brain cells that were sick from the stroke--but not quite dead--becoming healthy and operational again. By contrast, improvement in language function occurring over ensuing weeks, months and even years is due to the retraining of surviving brain cells that take over for their fallen comrades. A younger stroke patient with more brain cells in reserve has a better chance for recovery than an older patient with fewer reserves.

Is there anything that can be done to improve outcome? First of all, there is the management of the stroke itself which generally takes place in a hospital. One important point to emphasize is that a stroke causing aphasia is no less a stroke than one causing paralysis of muscles. Sometimes it seems that the latter receives more serious attention than the former. Management of fundamental issues--like blood pressure, body temperature and blood sugar--can set the stage for the best possible outcome.

Following a first stroke, physicians also implement "secondary stroke prevention" to decrease the odds of a second stroke. In cases of stroke due to hardening of the arteries (atherosclerosis) this often takes the form of ratcheting down blood pressure, blood sugar and cholesterol, along with elimination of smoking and other unhealthy behaviors. Also, the doctor usually prescribes a medicine to reduce blood-clotting. Other causes of stroke might call for other measures.

Does speech therapy help stroke-patients with aphasia? So far, this form of treatment has not been proved beneficial. Randomized, controlled trials (the standard of proof in clinical medicine in which patients receiving the treatment are compared to similar patients receiving either a dummy-treatment or no treatment) have not clearly demonstrated that speech therapy is better than either no treatment or treatment provided by family or friends.

Sometimes patients with aphasia are perceived as "confused" in the sense of having a delirium or dementia. But this is not the case. Acutely aphasic patients need to be recognized as having suffered a stroke to a specific part of the brain so they can be triaged for appropriate medical care. Over the longer term, family and friends need to remember that the stroke victim is still a perceiving, self-aware human being who happens to have a communication problem. He or she should be loved, appreciated and otherwise included in activities just as before.

(C) 2005 by Gary Cordingley

Gary Cordingley, MD, PhD, is a clinical neurologist, teacher and researcher who works in Athens, Ohio. For more health-related articles see his website at: http://www.cordingleyneurology.com


MORE RESOURCES:

Language - Google News

This RSS feed URL is deprecated

This RSS feed URL is deprecated, please update. New URLs can be found in the footers at https://news.google.com/news

How Donald Trump is making racist language OK again - The Independent


The Independent

How Donald Trump is making racist language OK again
The Independent
Once upon a time, not too long ago, it was taboo for top level politicians to openly express racist sentiments. That's why they tended to use code words, talking about “inner city crime” or “welfare dependency”. These are dogwhistle terms, which have ...

Do Language Movement heroines get the recognition they deserve? - Dhaka Tribune


Dhaka Tribune

Do Language Movement heroines get the recognition they deserve?
Dhaka Tribune
The nation pays heartfelt tribute to the Language Movement martyrs and heroes on Language Martyrs' Day on February 21 every year. But very few programs or events commemorate, or even recognize the important role of the female protesters during the 1952 ...

Tribute to language martyrs - The Daily Star


The Daily Star

Tribute to language martyrs
The Daily Star
Just before midnight, as words to “Amar Bhaiyer Rokte Rangano”, began to waft through the air, the nation paid homage to the Language Movement martyrs. It was a show of respect for those who sacrificed their lives for the recognition of Bangla as a ...
Awami League set to observe Language Martyrs' Day Dhaka Tribune
Nation set to pay homage to language martyrs Prothom Alo English (satire) (press release) (blog)

all 13 news articles »

Macron's French language initiative meets resistance -- from French speakers - FRANCE 24


FRANCE 24

Macron's French language initiative meets resistance -- from French speakers
FRANCE 24
Among his many ambitious initiatives, French President Emmanuel Macron is looking to make his nation's language relevant again. Some in the Francophone world say the move stinks of colonialism. Macron's business-first reputation can lead one to forget ...

International Mother Language Day: A Day To Celebrate And Protect Linguistic Diversity And Multilinguism - NDTV


NDTV

International Mother Language Day: A Day To Celebrate And Protect Linguistic Diversity And Multilinguism
NDTV
One language disappears on average every two weeks, taking with it an entire cultural and intellectual heritage, says UNESCO (United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation). Keeping this in mind, the UN agency introduced ...
Are former model C schools using school language policies as a ... Independent Online
Cultural heritage is a child's right, so let's celebrate International ... ABC Online
Int'l Mother Language Day marked in Bangladesh Xinhua
Daily Pioneer  - bdnews24.com  - Yeni Şafak English
all 21 news articles »

How the language we use contributes to depression and anxiety - Aleteia EN


Aleteia EN

How the language we use contributes to depression and anxiety
Aleteia EN
It probably wouldn't surprise you to learn that people with depression, anxiety, and ideas of suicide use language differently than the general population. But the way their word choices differ just might. Most of us would assume that people who are ...

Language app Babbel translates European success to U.S. market - Reuters


Reuters

Language app Babbel translates European success to U.S. market
Reuters
It might seem a tall order to persuade people to spend as much to learn a language on their smartphone as it costs to subscribe to a music streaming or video-on-demand service.
Babbel language-learning app finally cracks the US market Business Day

all 1 news articles »

Do we make better decisions in a foreign language? - Financial Times


Financial Times

Do we make better decisions in a foreign language?
Financial Times
An American friend recently told me of a reunion with the son of the German family whose home he had lived in for a year as an exchange student. My friend had spent the year acquiring fluent German, which he spoke to the family. The reunion, several ...

Language started 1.5m years earlier than previously thought as ... - Telegraph.co.uk


Telegraph.co.uk

Language started 1.5m years earlier than previously thought as ...
Telegraph.co.uk
In the beginning was the word. And it was first spoken by Homo Erectus, according to a controversial new theory. Most paleontologists believe language emerged with the evolution of Homo Sapiens around 350,000 years ago. But Daniel Everett, Professor of ...

and more »

LargeFriends.com - the best dating site for plus-sized singles!
SuccessfulMatchCentral.com - the best dating site for plus-sized singles!

PreLaunchX

© www.KewlOz.com 2013

home | site map | links